Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • News
  • All
  • Arts
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
  • Local Events
  • Post an Event
  • Business Events
  • Games
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Legal

Pope’s Civil Union Comment Offers No Lifeline for Protecting Church-State Separation

By Andy Humm Posted on October 27, 2020
U.S. Senate holds confirmation hearing for Barrett to be Supreme Court justice in Washington
Reuters/ Samuel Corum
Sign up for our amNY Sports email newsletter to get insights and game coverage for your favorite teams

Old quotes by Pope Francis in a new documentary saying that gay people are “children of god and have a right to a family” and supporting the creation of “civil union” laws for gay couples so they are “legally covered” are not moving anti-gay groups to drop their lawsuit, Fulton v. Philadelphia, seeking the right of Catholic Social Services (CSS) of Philadelphia to discriminate against gay couples in foster care.

The Supreme Court and its new 6-3 conservative majority will hear oral arguments in the case on November 4, the day after the election that will deliver its verdict on President Donald Trump who put half of the conservatives on the high court.

This monumental civil rights case went unmentioned in the debate over the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett as Democrats avoided her radical views on “religious freedom” and focused instead on her opposition to the Affordable Care Act — coming before the court a week later — and to the court decisions opening marriage to same-sex couples.

Philadelphia Catholic foster care charity proceeds with Supreme Court challenge to city’s nondiscrimination ordinance

The high court will be deciding whether generally applicable laws can be ignored if an individual has a religious objection to them. All civil rights laws — federal, state, and local —would be undermined if the court sides with Fulton affecting not just LGBTQ people, but all protected classes. All someone would have to do if they objected to employing or providing a service to someone who was Black, female, or disabled, for example, is cite their “religious” objection to doing so.

On the chopping block in Fulton is the court’s landmark 1990 decision in Employment Division v. Smith that let Oregon deny unemployment benefits to two members of the Native American Church who ingested peyote, an illegal drug, in their religious ceremonies. In the majority opinion, Justice Antonin Scalia — for whom Barrett worked and who she said is her “originalist” role model — wrote that granting the plaintiffs the right to use illegal drugs “would open the prospect of constitutionally required religious exemptions from civic obligations of almost every conceivable kind — ranging from compulsory military service to the payment of taxes to health and safety regulation such as manslaughter and child neglect laws, compulsory vaccination laws, drug laws, and traffic laws; to social welfare legislation such as minimum wage laws, child labor laws, animal cruelty laws, environmental protection laws, and laws providing for equality of opportunity for the races.” But Barrett said in her confirmation hearing, “I am not Justice Scalia.”

Sharonell Fulton, a Catholic foster mother, wants Catholic Social Services to be able to receive city money for its foster care and adoption services while violating Philadelphia’s anti-discrimination laws and only work with parents who are Catholic and in heterosexual married couples or single and non-gay. Lower federal courts have affirmed the city’s right to enforce its laws banning its contractors from discriminating. (New York has similar laws. Religiously-affiliated contractors must certify that they will abide in their provision of services by city and state laws banning bias on a variety of bases including sexual orientation and gender identity. Catholic and Orthodox Jewish agencies make these certifications.)

Now that the pope has publicly affirmed gay families is Catholic Social Services abandoning their suit?

In response to questions regarding the impact of Francis’ statement on their case, the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, attorneys for Fulton, responded with a statement from the Catholic Archdiocese of Philadelphia, stating, “There has been much recent attention paid to comments attributed to the Holy Father in a documentary that premiered in Rome this week. It is important to note that the remarks appeared in the context of a film and not a Church teaching document. Further, the references involved civil unions. The Holy Father has consistently affirmed the Sacrament of Marriage as a union between one man and one woman on many occasions just as he has affirmed the need to treat all people with respect and dignity. The recent comments underscore the Holy Father’s previous calls for pastoral and cultural sensitivity to the many different journeys of those who walk through life around us.”

Rick Esenberg, president and general counsel for the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty who is representing the interests of the Catholic Archdiocese of Milwaukee in the case, wrote in an email, “The Pope’s comments have no impact. When presented with a claim that a person’s religion would be substantially burdened by a law, a Court is not free to inquire whether a person’s position is theologically correct or sanctioned by some religious authority. It must accept it. Even were the Pope to formally change Catholic doctrine in the context of an interview — and it is our understanding that that is not typical practice — what would remain important is the Plaintiff’s claim that her faith is burdened by the challenged requirement.”

The lead respondents in the case — the American Civil Liberties Union, representing the Support Center for Child Advocates and Philadelphia Family Pride, and Neal Katyal, the acting solicitor general under President Barack Obama who is representing the city of Philadelphia — declined to comment on the effect of the Pope’s remarks.

But Patrick Elliott, senior counsel of the Freedom From Religion Foundation, which is helping contest Fulton’s suit, wrote in an email, “I do not think this will change anything related to the Fulton case. Even if Catholic Social Services was disobeying directions from Pope Francis, the Supreme Court would not delve into the proper interpretation of Catholic doctrine. So as long as CSS expresses a desire to continue to discriminate against same-sex couples who want to participate in the city’s foster care program, the case will proceed. Of course, if CSS had a change of heart that would moot the case.”

CSS did not return Gay City News’ call.

Jennifer Pizer, law and policy director for Lambda Legal who is representing LGBTQ youth organizations in their amicus brief in the case, said that she hoped Catholic Social Services would “take seriously the guidance from the Pope.” But she said the high court justices “should not be affected” by the pronouncements of Francis any more that by those of the more conservative Pope Benedict XVI.

James K. Riley, a New Jersey attorney who filed an amicus brief on behalf of 27 Catholic lay persons supporting the city of Philadelphia’s position, said, the pope’s sentiments reflect those of “millions of Catholics” and are “a great step.”

He added, “Nobody is asking Catholic Social Services” to affirm “sacramental marriage” for gay couples.

Father Bernárd Lynch, an out gay priest, therapist, and theologian, now lives in his native Catholic Ireland where abortion and same-sex marriage were legalized by referendum, but he pointed out that doesn’t mean people have to believe they are “moral.”

He said, “What the pope says is important, but is not ‘the word of God.’”

Lynch said he would say to Catholic Social Services, “You have no right to impose your morality on anybody. You are bound by the law of the land.” He added that when religious people start saying they are not bound by civil law, “there’s no difference between that and Sharia law.”

Separation of church and state had been a longstanding American principle and quality — allowing organized religion to thrive in contrast to the ways in which it has withered in many countries in Europe with state religions. An increasingly conservative Supreme Court has been chipping away at that separation in recent years — most startlingly in its 2014 Hobby Lobby ruling that found that the closely held private company could claim a religious exemption from complying with the contraceptive coverage requirements of the Affordable Care Act.

Evan Wolfson, pioneer in the fight for same-sex marriage since the 1980s and counsel in this case for the National Women’s Law Center and 35 additional organizations that filed an amicus brief, said, “You are entitled to believe what you want. The problem is that you can’t have law where everyone gets to impose their own religious beliefs — or beliefs cloaked in religion — as a special exemption from following the law.

Wolfson worries about Justices Barrett, Samuel Alito, and Clarence Thomas.

“They are intolerant and extreme” on these issues, he said. “But we have to be hopeful. If we lose this case we have to keep fighting.”

Wolfson is now on the board of Take Back the Court whose mission sates, “To restore the right to vote, ensure reproductive freedom, protect workers, halt our climate emergency, and save democracy, Congress must add seats to the US Supreme Court.”

Vice President Joe Biden has said he will appoint a bipartisan commission to look at the make-up of the federal courts, but it is the responsibility of the Congress to set the number of federal judges and circuits at all levels, including the US Supreme Court.

To sign up for the Gay City News email newsletter, visit gaycitynews.com/newsletter.

About the Author

Jobs in New York

Add your job

  • Mark Morris Dance GroupFacilities Supervisor
  • SmartCap Funding Junior Account reps
  • Fresh & Tasty Baked ProductsClerical Customer Service

View all jobs…

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

Post an Event

Queers N Peers variety show returns with
Tomorrow, 7 pm

Queers N Peers: Sacrilege
Dromedary Bar

A long-time self-proclaimed “21st-Centur
March 24, 7 pm

Phantoms of the Cabaret
triad theater

Step aside, Babadook… there is a new gay
March 30, 7 pm

M3GAN: The Parody Musical
Caveat

New York Times bestselling author, pione
March 30, 7 pm

Rita Mae Brown, in conversation with Felice Cohen
THE CENTER

On International Trans Day of Visibility
March 31, 3 pm

International Trans Day of Visibility with Black Trans Femmes in the Arts
Brooklyn Museum

Join comedian/musician Tessa Skara (HBO
April 2, 8 pm

GAY CHURCH with Tessa Skara
C’mon Everybody

View All Events…

Arts

  • Pakistani director/cowriter Saim Sadiq’s extraordinary feature debut, “Joyland,” depicts the relationship that develops between the married Haider (Ali Junejo) and the trans Biba (Alina Khan) when he takes a job as one of her backup dancers. Spring LGBTQ film guide: What to watch this season
  • The Leslie-Lohman Museum of Art's current exhibition, “Images on which to build, 1970s – 1990s,” runs until July 30. The archive is the agent: Exhibition charts trans, feminist, and lesbian educational projects of the 1970s to 1990s
  • "The Five Devils" opens March 27th at the Angelika Film Center. ‘The Five Devils’: smells, supernatural powers, and ominous imagery
  • Patrons discuss Craig Anthony Miller’s (aka CAM) artwork on the wall from their bar stool at Superfine’s sunken bar in September 2022. Brooklyn’s queer-owned Superfine restaurant blends art, food, and music
  • The electronic punk duo Sleaford Mods are up to their 12th album. March LGBTQ music: Sleaford Mods and 100 gecs

Politics

  • Out gay Congressmember Mark Pocan is pushing back against a GOP-led attack on LGBTQ youth. GOP-led House committee passes federal ban on trans student-athletes
  • Forest Hills lawyer launches campaign to become Queens County’s first openly gay elected judge
  • Marti Cummings, Assemblymember Tony Simone, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, and Jackie Cox. Assemblymember Tony Simone inaugurated in style in Chelsea
  • Tennessee restricts drag shows, bans gender-affirming care for youth
  • Councilmember Vickie Paladino has developed a reputation for making anti-LGBTQ remarks on social media. Council removes anti-LGBTQ Vickie Paladino from Mental Health Committee

Crime

  • Elected officials call on city to keep disciplinary trial date in Trawick case
  • A picture of John Umberger. Medical examiner declares two gay men died by drug-facilitated homicides
  • A new Rainbow Flag flies at Little Prince hours after an arsonist set the previous flag on fire. New Rainbow Flag goes up hours after Manhattan arson; suspect arrested
  • Op-Ed | Keeping New York the safest large city in America
  • Deandre Matthews standing on a sidewalk. Gay man fatally shot and burned in Brooklyn

Perspectives

  • Why I cover and march in St. Patrick’s Day Parades
  • Food Bank For New York City CEO Leslie Gordon. Fighting food insecurity in LGBTQ community requires multi-faceted approach
  • RaySean Dixon Cultural competence in health care is a necessity
  • Santos’ ‘groomer’ rhetoric highlights hypocrisy
  • Democratic Senator Raphael Warnock waves to supporters during his election night party. In a troubled time, Warnock victory inspires and informs us

Related Articles

  • Costa Rica Is Central America’s First to Legalize Same-Sex Marriage
  • Ecuador’s High Court Legalizes Same-Sex Marriage
  • NYC Activists Rally For Marriage Equality in Taiwan
  • Remembering How Gay Lawyers Became Legal

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

New York’s Job Board

More from Around NYC

miss american pie interior
Brooklyn Paper

The day the pie survived: Miss American Pie won’t say ‘bye-bye’ to Park Slope

worldcup_ramblinghouse_cornerbar-scaled
Bronx Times

Borough president’s office to celebrate Irish Heritage Month in Woodlawn

Tenants protest Gov. Kathy Hochul at a rally for Good Cause eviction protections.
Caribbean Life

Protesters call out Hochul for failing to support tenants in state budget

Jets trade Elijah Moore to Browns
AMNY

Jets trade disgruntled receiver Elijah Moore to Browns for 2nd rounder

Get the Gay City Newsletter

Sign up for our regular & breaking news updates.

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Networking Events
  • Advertise
  • © Gay City News 2023. Schneps Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sections
  • Jobs
  • Games
  • Events
  • Contact