Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • News
  • All
  • Arts
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
  • Local Events
  • Post an Event
  • Business Events
  • Games
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Legal

Michigan Court Splits Verdict on Anti-Gay, Anti-Trans Discrimination

By Arthur S. Leonard Posted on December 14, 2020
Dana-Nessel-michigan nondiscrimination
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, only the second out lesbian elected to such a post nationwide, is appealing the Court of Claims ruling.
Human Rights Campaign
Sign up for our amNY Sports email newsletter to get insights and game coverage for your favorite teams

Relying on a 1993 opinion from Michigan’s intermediate-level appellate court, a Court of Claims judge ruled on December 7 that the state’s Elliot-Larsen Civil Rights Act (ELCRA) — which among others things prohibits businesses from discriminating against customers because of their sex — cannot be interpreted as banning sexual orientation discrimination.

Judge Christopher M. Murray, ruling on December 7 in Rouch World v. Michigan Department of Civil Rights (MDCR), looked to a 17-year-old precedent from the Michigan Court of Appeals.

Significantly, however, the Michigan Supreme Court recently vacated a Court of Appeals ruling that a separate hate crimes statute does not protect transgender people. It ordered the intermediate level bench to reconsider the issue in light of the US Supreme Court’s June ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, which found that both gender identity and sexual orientation are protected classes under the Title VII employment nondiscrimination provision of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. The state’s highest court, then, is prepared to treat Bostock as a persuasive precedent for interpreting the state’s sex discrimination laws — an inclination at odds with Murray’s ruling last week in the public accommodations case.

Trial judge sees precedent against honoring sexual orientation claim, but not gender identity suit

Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, who is the nation’s second out lesbian elected to such a post — after Massachusetts’ Maura Healy — announced that the state would appeal Murray’s ruling regarding sexual orientation discrimination.

Murray did, however, find that discrimination against transgender people in public accommodations is covered by ELCRA’s sex discrimination ban, in that instance relying on the Bostock ruling. The business facing the gender identity discrimination claim has announced that it is appealing that portion of Murray’s ruling.

The case at issue involved discrimination claims against two businesses. Rouch World, an events venue that rents space for weddings and other celebrations, refused to book a wedding for a same-sex couple, citing the owners’ religious objections to same-sex marriages.

Uprooted Electrolysis, which provides permanent hair-removal treatment, turned down a transgender person seeking their service as part of her transition, also citing religious objections.

The customers rejected by each business filed complaints with MDCR, which has interpreted ELCRA to cover nondiscrimination claims based on sexual orientation and gender identity. The businesses then filed suit in the Court of Claims, arguing the department lacks jurisdiction on this question, and that in any event their religious objections would override any nondiscrimination requirements under the civil rights act.

Murray explained that ELCRA does not define the word “sex” in the provision applicable to “a place of public accommodation,” which includes businesses selling goods or services to the public.

In 1993, the Michigan Court of Appeals ruled that “harassment or discrimination based on a person’s sexual orientation is not an activity proscribed by the Act.”

That decision is binding on trial courts in Michigan.

Murray explained that whether that “reasoning is no longer valid in light of Bostock v. Clayton County… is a matter for the Court of Appeals, not this court.”

That conclusion of course made Nessel’s appeal inevitable — even if it had not already been so.

Murray, however, found no prior opinion by a Michigan court addressing the question of whether gender identity discrimination claims are covered by ELCRA. Lacking the guidance of any state court precedent, the judge looked to Bostock.

The Michigan Supreme Court’s recent ruling vacating the Court of Appeals decision involved the intermediate appellate bench finding that the state’s ethnic intimidation act inclusion of sex as a protected class did not cover hate crimes against trans people. The high court instructed the Court of Appeals to reconsider the issue in light of Bostock.

The bottom line of Judge Murray’s decision is that MDCR does not have jurisdiction over the sexual orientation discrimination claim against Rouch World unless the Michigan Court of Appeals overrules its 1993 decision, but that it does have jurisdiction to investigate Uprooted Electrolysis’s denial of service to a transgender client.

Of course, the Michigan Supreme Court’s order in the ethnic intimidation case is likely to persuade the Court of Appeals that it should also reconsider the 1993 ruling in light of Bostock.

Murray refrained from ruling on the businesses’ religious exemption claims, stating that issue “has not been sufficiently briefed to resolve at this juncture.”

The question of federal constitutional religious exemptions from complying with state or local anti-discrimination laws is now before the US Supreme Court in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia — which involves the city’s decision now to renew a foster care contract with Catholic Social Services, which refuses to accept same-sex couples as clients. The case was argued at the high court on November 4 and will be decided sometime in 2021.

It is likely that many state agencies and courts will defer decisions on religious exemption claims pending that ruling.

To sign up for the Gay City News email newsletter, visit gaycitynews.com/newsletter.

About the Author

Jobs in New York

Add your job

  • Fresh & Tasty Baked ProductsClerical Customer Service
  • Mark Morris Dance GroupFacilities Supervisor
  • WorkTimeJunior Marketing Specialist

View all jobs…

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

Post an Event

Queer Speed Dating in Williamsburg @ 3 D
Tomorrow, 7 pm

Gay Men Speed Dating at Brooklyn’s Premiere Queer Bar & Performance Venue
3 Dollar Bill

Presented by Diverse Streets Initiative.
March 23, 5 pm

Solidarity & Safe Spaces – Diverse Streets Initiative – Art Exhibition
Culture Lab LIC

Make your Sunday extra special with Quee
March 26, 12:30 pm

Queen Supreme Brunch Cabaret Presented by House of Yes
Everdene

Step aside, Babadook… there is a new gay
March 30, 7 pm

M3GAN: The Parody Musical
Caveat

New York Times bestselling author, pione
March 30, 7 pm

Rita Mae Brown, in conversation with Felice Cohen
THE CENTER

Dear Mom, I’m Gay! is a new musical by D
April 8, 3 pm

Laura Bell Bundy: “Dear Mom, I’m Gay!” Fundraiser Concert
The Marjorie S. Deane Little Theater

View All Events…

Arts

  • Patrons discuss Craig Anthony Miller’s (aka CAM) artwork on the wall from their bar stool at Superfine’s sunken bar in September 2022. Brooklyn’s queer-owned Superfine restaurant blends art, food, and music
  • The electronic punk duo Sleaford Mods are up to their 12th album. March LGBTQ music: Sleaford Mods and 100 gecs
  • Three people in a scene from "Rodeo." Q&A with “Rodeo” filmmaker Lola Quivoron
  • Beth B's “Two Small Bodies"part of “Sex, Power & Money: Films by Beth B” at Metrograph March 10-13. Beth B’s films look back at a queer, punk downtown New York scene
  • Sabine Devieilhe as Sister Constance in Poulenc's "Dialogues des Carmélites." From Schubert to Strayhorn, gay composers find voice in New York and Paris

Politics

  • Out gay Congressmember Mark Pocan is pushing back against a GOP-led attack on LGBTQ youth. GOP-led House committee passes federal ban on trans student-athletes
  • Forest Hills lawyer launches campaign to become Queens County’s first openly gay elected judge
  • Marti Cummings, Assemblymember Tony Simone, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, and Jackie Cox. Assemblymember Tony Simone inaugurated in style in Chelsea
  • Tennessee restricts drag shows, bans gender-affirming care for youth
  • Councilmember Vickie Paladino has developed a reputation for making anti-LGBTQ remarks on social media. Council removes anti-LGBTQ Vickie Paladino from Mental Health Committee

Crime

  • Elected officials call on city to keep disciplinary trial date in Trawick case
  • A picture of John Umberger. Medical examiner declares two gay men died by drug-facilitated homicides
  • A new Rainbow Flag flies at Little Prince hours after an arsonist set the previous flag on fire. New Rainbow Flag goes up hours after Manhattan arson; suspect arrested
  • Op-Ed | Keeping New York the safest large city in America
  • Deandre Matthews standing on a sidewalk. Gay man fatally shot and burned in Brooklyn

Perspectives

  • Why I cover and march in St. Patrick’s Day Parades
  • Food Bank For New York City CEO Leslie Gordon. Fighting food insecurity in LGBTQ community requires multi-faceted approach
  • RaySean Dixon Cultural competence in health care is a necessity
  • Santos’ ‘groomer’ rhetoric highlights hypocrisy
  • Democratic Senator Raphael Warnock waves to supporters during his election night party. In a troubled time, Warnock victory inspires and informs us

Related Articles

  • In Indiana, County Clerk Can’t Refuse to Issue License
  • GOP to Gays: Drop Dead
  • With Pence Pick, Trump Bets on Hard Right
  • Federal Court Blocks Anti-LGBT Mississippi Law

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

New York’s Job Board

More from Around NYC

police investigate scene of crown heights shooting
Brooklyn Paper

One dead in shooting outside Crown Heights bodega

Bronx Armory 3
Bronx Times

Kingsbridge Armory rally, public workshop sets the stage for upcoming proposal

Puerto Rico Bad Bunny Lawsuit
Caribbean Life

Bad Bunny’s ex-girlfriend files lawsuit seeking $40M

Lance Reddick
AMNY

Lance Reddick talked ‘mind-blowing’ action of upcoming ‘John Wick: Chapter 4’ in interview the day before his death

Get the Gay City Newsletter

Sign up for our regular & breaking news updates.

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Networking Events
  • Advertise
  • © Gay City News 2023. Schneps Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sections
  • Jobs
  • Games
  • Events
  • Contact