Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • News
  • All
  • Arts
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
  • Local Events
  • Post an Event
  • Business Events
  • Games
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Families

For Now, NYS Can’t Penalize Anti-Gay Adoption Agency

By Arthur S. Leonard Posted on October 19, 2020
New Hope Family Services
Following an order by US District Judge Mae D’Agostino, the adoption agency New Hope Family Services can continue to discriminate against same-sex couples and single people by withholding its services from them.
New Hope Family Services
Sign up for our amNY Sports email newsletter to get insights and game coverage for your favorite teams

New Hope Family Services, a Christian adoption agency licensed by New York State, has won a preliminary injunction to block the state’s Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS) from closing the agency because of its refusal to provide services to married same-sex couples.

US District Judge Mae A. D’Agostino issued the injunction on October 5 after being directed by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals to reconsider her prior denial of a preliminary injunction at the same time that she dismissed New Hope’s lawsuit. The Second Circuit panel reversed her dismissal.

Under New York law, only an “authorized agency” can evaluate potential adoptive parents, match them with children needing adoption, and make recommendations to a court that ultimately grants the adoption.

New Hope Family Services wins temporary injunction as it pleads religious freedom discrimination

New Hope, originally named Evangelical Family Service, was formed in 1965 by a Syracuse-based Christian minister. In the 1960s, New York’s adoption statute limited the right to adopt children to “an adult unmarried person or an adult husband and his adult wife.”

In 2010, the legislature — complying with the state’s highest court practice of recognizing second-parent adoptions for same-sex couples since the 1990s — amended the law to allow authorized agencies to place children for adoption with “an adult unmarried person, an adult married couple together, or any two unmarried adult intimate partners together.”

OCFS, in turn, adopted a non-discrimination regulation and informed all authorized agencies that they could not discriminate against same-sex couples or unmarried couples. After New York’s Marriage Equality Law went into effect in 2011, of course, married same-sex couples were automatically covered by the amended statute, and authorized agencies were so advised. In 2015, the US Supreme Court found that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry, and their marriages are entitled to the same treatment under state law as all other marriages.

New Hope, however, retained its longstanding policy of limiting its services to married different-sex couples or unmarried adults not living in an intimate relationship with another adult. For any other couple who approached New Hope, it had a policy of “recusal and referral” to a different agency.

OCFS never received any complaints about New Hope denying services, but a 2018 audit of authorized adoption agencies brought its discriminatory policy to light. The conversations that ensued between OCFS and New Hope included some statements that the agency seized upon as showing “hostility” to its religious beliefs — and the Second Circuit panel felt that claim was at least arguable. When it was given a written ultimatum in late 2018, New Hope filed this lawsuit, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, a leading anti-LGBTQ religious litigation group.

New Hope argued that OCFS’ regulation went beyond the statute, which it said was permissive in allowing agencies to serve same-sex couples as well as unmarried couples. The lawsuit noted that at the time it was adopted, Governor David Paterson stated it would not require any agencies to change their polices.

New Hope also asserted that requiring it to serve same-sex couples contrary to its religious beliefs violates its First Amendment rights of free speech and free exercise of religion. Citing the US Supreme Court’s 2018 Masterpiece Cakeshop decision, New Hope also claimed that OCFS had expressed hostility to the agency’s religious beliefs. It sought a preliminary injunction to block OCFS from taking action against it while the lawsuit was pending.

The state moved to dismiss the lawsuit.

Judge D’Agostino granted the state’s motion, finding that the regulation was within the scope of the statute and did not violate New Hope’s constitutional rights.

New Hope appealed to the Second Circuit, which reversed D’Agostino’s dismissal in July and sent the case back to her. The three-judge Circuit panel concluded that New Hope’s allegations were sufficient to put into play its constitutional claims as well as its claims about the limited scope of the adoption statute as permissive rather than mandatory. The panel, which also mentioned the “hostility” issue, retained jurisdiction of the case, advising that any appeal of D’Agostino’s new decision would return to it.

Given those directives, D’Agostino’s new injunction was inevitable, though her opinion included signs she had not changed her mind about her original analysis.

In one footnote, responding to the issue of “hostility,” she wrote, “In conducting its analysis, the Court cannot ignore the drastic difference in the circumstances which have historically led to findings of religious hostility and the circumstances of the present case… Here, the only statements upon which the Second Circuit relies indicate, at worst, that OCFS intends to ensure compliance with anti-discrimination law in the adoption process, regardless of an organization’s religious beliefs. The Court finds the argument that these statements indicate hostility tenuous.”

Still, D’Agostino acknowledged she was bound by the Second Circuit’s opinion to credit this argument in deciding whether to issue the preliminary injunction.

At the heart of the constitutional free exercise issue is the US Supreme Court’s 1990 decision in Employment Division v. Smith, which found that there is no constitutional right under the Free Exercise Clause for individuals and organizations to refuse to comply with religiously-neutral laws of general application that incidentally burden their free exercise rights. The Supreme Court recognized, however, that a government policy that burdens other rights as well as religious free exercise rights presents a different issue and may carry a higher burden of justification.

New Hope had argued that requiring it to recommend to a court an adoption by a same-sex couple was “compelled speech,” but D’Agostino’s original response to this was to note that in acting as the “authorized agency” of OCFS, the agency was merely providing the court with “government speech” consistent with New York State policy.

Here, the Second Circuit panel disagreed, finding that the state gave authorized agencies substantial discretion, so their speech was entitled to First Amendment protection. It also concluded that New Hope’s argument that the regulation went beyond the scope of the statute, given its permissive rather than mandatory wording, deserved to be litigated.

The New Hope case is very similar to the case that will be argued in the Supreme Court on November 4, the day after the election, where Catholic Social Services is suing the City of Philadelphia over the city’s refusal to renew CSS’ contract to participate in the city’s foster care system. CSS, like New Hope, refused to provide its services to same-sex couples seeking to be foster parents. In its petition to the high court to review the Third Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision in favor of the city, CSS specifically asked the court both to reconsider its ruling in Employment Division v. Smith and to decide whether requiring a religious agency to violate is principles so that it can participate in the child welfare system violates its First Amendment rights.

It is unlikely that D’Agostino would issue a final ruling in the New Hope case until the Supreme Court rules in the CSS case — a decision that probably won’t come until 2021, perhaps as late as next June. In the meanwhile, the preliminary injunction blocks OCFS from taking any action to shut down New Hope’s adoption activities.

D’Agostino was appointed to the court by President Barack Obama.

To sign up for the Gay City News email newsletter, visit gaycitynews.com/newsletter.

About the Author

Jobs in New York

Add your job

  • Dmoch & Skulikidis, PLLCResourceful Assistant,
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle PlacePERSONAL DE LIMPIEZA
  • Catholic Guardian Services Family Enrichment Center Director

View all jobs…

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

Post an Event

Join Christopher Street Tours for a Vill
Tomorrow, 11 am

Village Pride Walking Tour with Christopher Street Tours
McCarthy Square

Join the To Proudly Go crew for the Star
Tomorrow, 6 pm

Star Trek: Lower Decks Viewing Party, Season 4
Barracuda Lounge

Hosted and produced by Reductress headli
Sept. 28, 9 pm

DRULE Comedy
Fette Sau

The NYC Mid Autumn Festival is a full da
Sept. 30, noon

NYC Mid Autumn Festival 2023
Trans-Pecos

Panty Raid Comedy Presents… Wet Hot Amer
Oct. 5, 9:30 pm

PANTY RAID COMEDY
Caveat

Marble Collegiate Church’s annual Blessi
Oct. 8, 12:15 pm

Blessing of the Animals at Marble Church
Marble Collegiate Church

View All Events…

Arts

  • Amanda Darrow, director of youth, family and education programs at the Utah Pride Center, poses with books that have been the subject of complaints from parents on Dec. 16, 2021, in Salt Lake City. Challenges to library books continue at record pace in 2023, American Library Association reports
  • "The Origin of Evil," directed by Sébastien Marnier, is playing at the IFC Center and other locations in New York. Lesbian’s family reunion leaves more questions than answers in ‘The Origin of Evil’
  • Bethann Hardison, who emerged as a model in New York in the 1970s, founded her own modeling agency in 1984. Documentaries recall the fashion legacies of Donyale Luna and Bethann Hardison
  • “Back to the Future: The Musical” is at Winter Garden Theater at 1634 Broadway. ‘Back to the Future’ is an irresistible joyride
  • John Osborne and TJ Osborne of Brothers Osborne. September LGBTQ music: Brothers Osborne and Jlin

Politics

  • Daniel O'Donnell represents Manhattan's District 69 in the New York State Assembly. Assemblymember O’Donnell ordered to undergo retraining
  • Marty Algaze at a 2015 Stonewall Democratic Club of NYC event. Marty Algaze, co-founder of Stonewall Democratic Club of NYC, dies at 72
  • Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis speaks during a news conference to sign several bills related to public education and increases in teacher pay, in Miami, on May 9, 2023. Florida imposes stricter anti-trans bathroom policy
  • Former Vice President Mike Pence speaks as Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis listens during a Republican presidential primary debate hosted by FOX News Channel Wednesday, Aug. 23, 2023, in Milwaukee. GOP presidential hopefuls assail trans rights at first Republican debate
  • Youth groups rally at NYPD headquarters demanding that cops who killed Kawaski Trawick be fired

Crime

  • A collection of Rainbow Flags blow in the wind at Christopher Park. Two more suspects arrested for vandalizing Rainbow Flags near Stonewall
  • Man indicted for hate crime after allegedly attacking transgender woman on Bed-Stuy subway
  • Different Rainbow Flags line the fence at Christopher Park. Man arrested for vandalizing Rainbow Flags near Stonewall
  • Man still sought for hurling anti-LGBTQ remarks at, slugging Hudson River Park jogger
  • Cedar Glen community member Trish Forest leaves flowers for Laura Ann "Lauri" Carleton outside Mag.Pi, the store she owned and operated, on Tuesday, Aug. 22, 2023. Killer of Mag.Pi store owner had history of anti-LGBTQ social media posts

Perspectives

  • An important message for the anti-trans lawmakers pushing transphobic legislation in statehouses across the country. Courts offer glimmer of hope during a painful year
  • mpox vaccine site Get fully vaccinated against mpox to protect yourself and our community
  • A Pride event at Yeshiva University in 2019. Time to recognize the YU Pride Alliance
  • A previous Brooklyn Liberation march and rally focused on trans youth. Celebrate International Transgender Day of Visibility by protecting trans kids
  • Why I cover and march in St. Patrick’s Day Parades

Related Articles

  • Alliance Defending Freedom’s Latest Swat at LGBTQ Rights
  • Movement Against Conversion Therapy Accelerates
  • Challenge to Trans Student Bathroom Access Advances
  • Cabrera’s Enduring Religious Homophobia

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

New York’s Job Board

More from Around NYC

east new york protected bike lanes
Brooklyn Paper

East New York’s longest protected bike lanes nearly complete, DOT says

1923 and 2023 COTM
Bronx Times

Celebrating community and history, Church of the Master approaches its centennial

President Joe Biden.
Caribbean Life

Biden extends TPS for Venezuelans

draftkings kentucky promo code
AMNY

DraftKings Kentucky promo code: Bet NFL Week 4 with $200 bonus

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Networking Events
  • Advertise
  • © Gay City News 2023. Schneps Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sections
  • Jobs
  • Games
  • Events
  • Contact