Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • News
  • All
  • Arts
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
  • Local Events
  • Post an Event
  • Business Events
  • Games
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Legal

Catholic Agency Religious Opt-Out Claim Goes to Supreme Court

By Arthur S. Leonard Posted on February 24, 2020
leslie-cooper-aclu-philadelphia-foster-care
The ACLU’s Leslie Cooper joined Philadelphia’s chief deputy solicitor in arguing in defense of the city’s policy on foster care services nondiscrimination.
Aclu.org

The US Supreme Court will review an appellate court ruling that rejected First Amendment claims by the Catholic Social Services (CSS) agency in Philadelphia that lost its foster care services contract with the city by refusing to work with same-sex couples. Last year, a unanimous three-judge panel of the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, affirmed a ruling by District Judge Petrese B. Tucker rejecting a request by the Catholic agency for a preliminary injunction against the city.

Since the high court will not hear arguments in the current term beyond April 29, this case won’t be argued until its fall term beginning in October.

CSS, an affiliate of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, had contracted with the city to perform foster care services for more than a century. This case was sparked in March 2018 when the Philadelphia Inquirer reported that two foster care agencies, CSS and Bethany Christian Services, told the newspaper they would not certify same-sex couples to be foster parents. Among 30 agencies under contract with the city, most of them faith-based, all the others stated they did work with same-sex couples.

CSS argued that consistent with Catholic doctrine it would certify only single individuals or married couples to be foster parents and that a same-sex couple would not be recognized as married regardless of the law. Responding to the Inquirer article, the City Council called on the City Commission on Human Relations to investigate the policies of the Philadelphia Department of Human Services on discrimination against LGBTQ foster parents.

Close

Never Miss a Beat

Sign up for email updates.
Thank you for subscribing!

City officials tried to negotiate a way around this problem with CSS and Bethany, with Bethany relenting but CSS refusing to budge. So, the city put a freeze on referrals to CSS and later refused to renew its contract.

Enlisting some foster parents as co-plaintiffs, CSS filed a lawsuit, represented by its counsel and attorneys from the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty.

CSS asserts that in a century of working with the city, it has never been approached by a same-sex couple and said it would refer such a couple to another agency.

The CSS lawsuit made several claims, including that the city’s anti-discrimination ordinance, which forbids sexual orientation discrimination, does not apply to it because it is not a “public accommodation.” And the agency claimed that under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, it has a right to deny services to same-sex couples on religious grounds and that it was being targeted for “selective enforcement” because of its Catholic religious views. Finally, CSS claimed that requiring it to certify same-sex couples as qualified foster parents is government-compelled speech, also prohibited by the First Amendment.

The American Civil Liberties Union represents Support Center for Child Advocates and Philadelphia Family Pride, which were granted intervener status in the case as co-defendants with the city. ACLU attorney Leslie Cooper participated in the hearing before the Third Circuit together with Jane Istvan, the city’s chief deputy solicitor.

Judge Tucker rejected CSS’s demand for preliminary relief, finding the agency was unlikely to win the case and that the city’s strong interest in enforcing its anti-discrimination policy would likely prevail. The Third Circuit panel — which included two judges appointed by President Bill Clinton and one by Ronald Reagan — found that CSS’ First Amendment arguments were without merit, relying heavily on the Supreme Court’s 1990 decision in Employment Division of Oregon v. Smith.

In the Smith case, the Supreme Court dealt with a claim by two men denied unemployment benefits after their employer fired them for flunking a drug test. The employees said that their positive tests resulted from using peyote during a Native American religious ceremony and argued that the government denying them unemployment benefits violated their right to free exercise of religion.

Writing for the Court, Justice Antonin Scalia, a devout Catholic, rejected the employees’ argument in an opinion that marked a radical change in First Amendment law. He held that individuals may not assert a free exercise claim against a “neutral state law of general application.” If a law does not target religion and is applied generally, the state does not have a burden to justify it against an individual’s free exercise of religion claim. Scalia argued that letting people claim exemptions from complying with generally applicable statutes would substantially undermine the rule of law.

Smith has remained a controversial decision, and several Supreme Court justices — interestingly, those largely aligned with Scalia’s conservative thinking — have suggested that the court should reconsider it, something CSS asked it to do. The court’s grant of review includes that question and reconsidering that principle could create a substantial religious exemption particularly harmful to the LGBTQ community in seeking protection against discrimination.

The foster care situation in Philadelphia illustrates this point starkly. Though all the religiously-affiliated foster care agencies there, except for CSS, agreed they would serve same-sex couples, it’s unclear how many would do so if they believed they had a First Amendment right to refuse.

It’s worth noting that the Third Circuit specifically rejected CSS’s argument that its treatment by the city showed “hostility to religion” — clearly an effort to grab the lifeline that saved baker Jack Phillips in the 2018 Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission case. There, the Supreme Court reiterated the general rule from Smith but found that some members of the Commission had made remarks hostile to religion, denying Phillips a “neutral forum” to consider his defense against the discrimination charge.

The Supreme Court already has cases it is considering in this term that could potentially narrow or overrule Smith, so it is a bit odd that it granted review here instead of holding the CSS petition until after ruling in the other matters. On the other hand, CSS alternately argued that the Third Circuit’s decision was a misapplication of Smith, so perhaps the court saw a reason to treat this case differently.

The Third Circuit appeal attracted 16 amicus briefs, largely from organizations arrayed on each side of the religious freedom issue. Eight states joined in an amicus brief filed by the Texas attorney general supporting the CSS claim, while 17 states and the District of Columbia joined in an amicus brief filed by out lesbian Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey, siding with the City of Philadelphia. All the major LGBTQ rights legal organizations joined briefs supporting the city.

Meanwhile, in the current term, court-watchers await rulings on three LGBTQ-related anti-discrimination cases under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which were argued in early October.

About the Author

Related Articles

  • Anti-Gay Colorado Baker Prevails in Narrow Ruling
  • Unfit King Questions Trans Troops’ Fitness
  • The Fight for Marriage in Broad, Informed Context
  • Sexual Orientation Discrimination Revisited by Second Circuit

Jobs in New York

Add your job

  • The Center for Investigative ReportingDigital Fundraiser, Senior Manager
  • Zen Home Cleaning✨ Luxury Housekeeper – Upscale Manhattan and Brooklyn Residences ✨New York, NY
  • Vouch Inc.Software Engineer

View all jobs…

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

Post an Event

IN THEIR FOOTSTEPS transforms the untold
Today, 7 pm

In Their Footsteps
Bronx Music Hall Amphitheatre

In celebration of her inaugural season w
Today, 7 pm

Masterclass With Alicia Graf Mack
Ailey Extension

LGBTQIA+ musician / Billboard-charting a
Today, 7 pm

Rachael Sage and The Sequins to Play Album Release Show at The Cutting Room (10/23)
Cutting Room NYC

TARRYTOWN is a haunting queer, modern re
Today, 7:30 pm

TARRYTOWN – The legend of Sleepy Hollow, a new musical
the cell theatre

Benny & the JettsOpening October 202
Today, 8 pm

BENNY & THE JETTS
BACCA Arts Center

Benny & the JettsOpening October 202
Today, 8 pm

BENNY & THE JETTS
BACCA Arts Center

Get ready to witness an unforgettable ni
Today, 9:30 pm

Superstar Open Set
Pink Metal

WINNER – BEST ONE MAN SHOW – UNITED SOLO
Tomorrow, 7 pm

Under the Rainbow @ The United Solo Festival
Theatre Row, 410 W 42nd Street, NY, NY

View All Events…

Arts

  • Sasha Colby With Stripped II, Sasha Colby is turning vulnerability into performance art
  • Camryn Garrett is the author of “The Forgotten Summer of Seneca." Portal to the past: Author Camryn Garrett champions overlooked Black history for young readers
  • Bluestockings Cooperative abruptly closed last month. Bluestockings Cooperative’s abrupt closure sparks internal drama
  • A Lesbian and Transgender Flag Hangs Above a Portrait of Marsha P. Johnson. Gladys Wine & Books: A new space for Black queer femmes in Brooklyn
  • Participating artists (standing left to right) Sharon De La Cruz, Mariela Figueroa, Eliana Falcón-Dvorsky, Ivan Velez, and panel moderator Megami. From ‘cringe’ to celebration: Puerto Rican queer comics take the spotlight

Politics

  • Election day man at polls2025 Elections: What you need to know before voting
  • Zohran Mamdani, wearing a "Gays for Zohran" pin, delivers remarks to the crowd at a National Coming Out Day rally on Oct. 11. Hundreds join Gays for Zohran’s National Coming Out Day rally
  • Erik Bottcher at his 2021 election night party at The Chelsea Bell. Bottcher raises $683k in first 24 hours after announcing potential Congressional bid
  • Councilmember Erik Bottcher speaks at a Sept. 30 rally against the Trump administration's anti-trans funding cuts. Denouncing Trump, Bottcher explores bid for Congress in race to replace Nadler
  • Kei Williams, the executive director of New Pride Agenda, delivers remarks on the steps of The Tweed Courthouse in Manhattan on Sept. 30. Advocates rally against Trump administration’s anti-trans funding cuts in NYC

Crime

  • The corner of New Lots Ave. and Vermont St. in Brooklyn is where an alleged anti-LGBTQ attack took place on Oct. 5. Woman hit with a chair in alleged anti-LGBTQ attack in Brooklyn
  • Jacob Zieben-Hood, 34, was found dead hours after he allegedly told his father by phone that his husband was targeting him with knives. Manhattan DA charges man in series of alleged attacks against slain husband
  • Penn Station on Aug. 27, 2025. Lawmakers demand answers from Amtrak after hundreds of arrests at Penn Station men’s bathroom
  • Law enforcement officers set up barriers after a shooting at Annunciation Church, which is also home to an elementary school, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S. August 27, 2025. In wake of Minneapolis shooting, White House falsely suggests link between gender-affirming care and violence
  • Convicted rapist of transgender woman in Manhattan walks in handcuffs.Convicted Manhattan rapist gets 12 years in prison, feels wrath of his transgender victim at sentencing hearing

Perspectives

  • The Caribbean Equality Project team at their inaugural gala on Sept. 19. Caribbean Equality Project celebrates a decade of resistance and belonging
  • The right to use the bathroom is increasingly under threat in New York City. Stop the disgraceful attacks on bathrooms
  • Erik Bottcher at his 2021 election night party at The Chelsea Bell. Erik Bottcher is the voice we need in Congress
  • Émilia Decaudin For New York to remain a queer haven, we must build more homes
  • Ronald Porcelli is the director of the NYC Unity Project. How the NYC Unity Project’s Family Acceptance of LGBTQ+ Youth Initiative heals families and saves LGBTQ+ lives

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

New York’s Job Board

More from Around NYC

voter guide 2025 general election
Brooklyn Paper

Brooklyn Paper’s 2025 General Election Voter Guide: How and where to vote, who’s on the ballot, and more

Residents at Mitchel Houses in Mott Haven told the Bronx Times that they aren't able to cook, and at times don't have hot water following a partial collapse of one of the residential buildings due to a boiler explosion. Now U.S. Representative Ritchie Torres is calling on NYCHA to prioritize converting the complex to all-electric.
Bronx Times

Ritchie Torres calls on NYCHA to convert Mitchel Houses to electric energy, residents agree

Governor Hochul.
Caribbean Life

Hochul rips Republicans for spiking health care costs for New Yorkers

a street with bus, vehicle and parking lanes
AMNY

Queens gets quicker: City touts completion of 8 miles of new bus lanes on Hillside Avenue

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Networking Events
  • Advertise
  • © Gay City News 2025. Schneps Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sections
  • Jobs
  • Games
  • Events
  • Contact