Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • Jobs
  • News
    • All
    • Arts
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
    • Local Events
    • Post an Event
    • Business Events
    • Games
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Gay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New YorkGay City News: Serving gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender New York
  • News
  • All
  • Arts
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • Perspectives
  • Things to Do
  • Local Events
  • Post an Event
  • Business Events
  • Games
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Webinars
  • Podcasts
Legal

Amy Coney Barrett’s Threat to LGBTQ, Reproductive & Healthcare Rights

By Paul Schindler Posted on September 27, 2020
FILE PHOTO: U.S President Donald Trump holds an event to announce his nominee of U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit Judge Amy Coney Barrett to fill the Supreme Court seat
President Donald Trump with Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Amy Coney Barrett, the president’s nominee to fill the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s seat on the Supreme Court.
Reuters/ Carlos Barria

During a lecture at Florida’s Jacksonville University just days before the 2016 presidential election, Amy Coney Barrett, who was then a law professor at the University of Notre Dame, argued that Obergefell v. Hodges, the landmark Supreme Court ruling from the year before that acknowledged the right of same-sex couples to marry, was misunderstood by the public.

The question, she asserted, was not who was in favor of marriage equality and who was opposed, but rather “who gets to decide” — the courts or the legislative branch of the government.

The public’s confusion about what happened on June 26, 2015, Barrett asserted, was a “New York Times headline problem.”

In remarks largely focused on the late Justice Antonin Scalia, for whom she had clerked in the late 1990s and whom she revered, Obergefell was a classic example, in Barrett’s view, of how the liberal wing of the Supreme Court had taken the concept of “substantive due process” rights under the 14th Amendment far beyond where “originalists” like Scalia believed was merited.

Trump’s Supreme Court choice would move the high court sharply to the right

While Scalia believed that both constitutional and statutory language must be interpreted based on the original text and meaning of the words when written, justices embracing “substantive due process” allow the high court to say “for itself what it thinks those rights are, based on what it thinks contemporary values are at the time,” Barrett told her audience.

Close

Never Miss a Beat

Sign up for email updates.
Thank you for subscribing!

At the conclusion of her talk in Jacksonville, Barrett — whom President Donald Trump announced September 26 as his choice to fill the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s seat on the Supreme Court — said that in looking at the presidential election the following week, “The who decides question is a really important question to me.” She added that she worried “about my voice being taken away.”

Just what was Barrett’s voice on marriage equality?

An October 2015 open letter, to which she was among nearly 1,400 Catholic women signatories, stated that “marriage and family founded on the indissoluble commitment of a man and a woman — provide a sure guide to the Christian life, promote women’s flourishing, and serve to protect the poor and most vulnerable among us.”

Signing this letter three months after the high court had ruled that the Constitution guarantees the rights of same-sex couples to marry is clearly an indication that Barrett felt that, at least on the issue of marriage equality, her voice had been taken away.

The letter was posted on the website of the Ethics & Public Policy Center (EPPC), an interdenominational group based in Washington that touts itself as “defending American ideals” and has strong support among leading conservatives.

Barrett’s affiliation with the EPPC is not her only link to religious conservatives. She is also a member of People of Praise, a South Bend, Indiana-based group of Christians that grew out of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, which in the 1960s emphasized tradition in reaction to some of the liberalizing that took hold in the Church during that decade. People of Praise emphasizes strict gender roles, and for a time women in the group were labeled “handmaids,” a fact that has led some Barrett critics to simplistically tie her faith practice to the dystopian world described in Margaret Atwood’s 1985 novel “The Handmaid’s Tale.”

A deep dive into Barrett’s faith practices, however, is not necessary to raise alarms about the policy implications of her ties to the religious right. In 2017, when Barrett won her seat on the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, Lambda Legal cited a lecture she delivered that was paid for by the Alliance Defending Freedom, a litigation group that doggedly fights LGBTQ advances in federal and state courts nationwide.

In a release this past week, the Human Rights Campaign charged that Barrett’s remarks at Jacksonville University amounted to a defense of those Supreme Court justices who dissented in the Obergefell marriage equality case.

HRC also noted that, in the same lecture, she challenged the Obama administration’s conclusion that Title IX of the 1972 Education Amendments, which prohibits sex discrimination in schools receiving federal funding, requires that the gender identity of transgender students be respected.

“It does seem to strain the text of that statute to say that Title IX demands” that policy position, Barrett said.

In talking about the issue, she seemed insistent on misgendering transgender students who have claimed Title IX protections, referring to them several times as “someone who was physiologically a boy but identifying as a girl.”

Barrett’s views on Title IX have since been severely undermined by the Supreme Court, which in its June ruling in the Bostock case, found that employment discrimination based on gender identity and sexual orientation is prohibited sex discrimination under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

Interpretations of other federal nondiscrimination laws — in areas like housing, public accommodations, and education — typically rely on the high court’s view of Title VII, but even though federal courts have begun to do exactly that, the question of the breadth of the Bostock ruling has not yet been decided by the high court.

If confirmed by the Senate, Barrett would likely be among the conservative votes on that issue.

In predicting back in 2016 what would be big issues to come before the Supreme Court, Barrett mentioned not only Title IX but also religious exemptions.

In fact, the day after the presidential election, the Supreme Court will review a Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that rejected claims by the Catholic Social Services agency in Philadelphia that lost its foster care services contract with the city by refusing to work with same-sex couples. The Third Circuit, relied heavily on a 1990 decision, authored, ironically, by Scalia, that found there is no religious exemption from neutral laws of general application even if they incidentally impact somebody’s free exercise of religion.

If that precedent were overridden the door would be open to all manner of claims of religious opt-outs from nondiscrimination laws protecting the LGBTQ community.

Concern about how Barrett would react to the Catholic Social Services appeal assuming she were on the court by November 4, as Senate Republicans hope, is based in part on her stated views on the doctrine of stare decisis — the tradition by which the high court stands by its earlier precedents in the absence of “special justification” or “strong grounds.” In the past, including in Jacksonville, Barrett has suggested that stare decisis need not constrain the court, that it is more “a matter of policy,” rather than a “mandate.”

In 2017, Lambda noted that Barrett declined to say whether Obergefell qualified as a precedent that could not be overturned.

The precedent that creates the biggest concern among Barrett critics, however, is Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that found a constitutional right to abortion.

In her Jacksonville lecture, she suggested that “the core” of that ruling was unlikely to be overturned in the future, but said the Supreme Court would likely be amenable to greater restrictions on abortion access.

But in a 2003 law journal article, Barrett clearly suggested that Roe was “an erroneous decision,” that might be ripe for reconsideration by the Supreme Court.

The one thing her supporters and her opponents seem to agree on is that she would be an anti-Roe vote.

CNN’s Manu Raju tweeted that Missouri Republican Senator Josh Hawley, who has predicated his support for a high court nominee on their view that Roe was “wrongly decided,” told him, “As to the question on Roe — yes, I think she meets that standard.”

Meanwhile, in a joint statement opposing Barrett’s nomination, People for the American Way, Alliance for Justice, the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, and the National Women’s Law Center, emphasized “the importance of opposing any nominee who will gut and overturn Roe. v. Wade.”

Those groups along with HRC and Lambda Legal also pointed to the dangers Barrett’s nomination to the high court posed to the survival of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). The Obama administration’s signature healthcare achievement once again goes before the high court in November.

In a 2017 law journal article, Barrett quoted Scalia’s critique of the two cases in which the high court upheld the ACA, saying it should be re-dubbed SCOTUSCare. Chief Justice John Roberts’ 2012 opinion that found the law’s individual mandate constitutional as an appropriate use of Congress’ taxing authority, she argued, pushed its text “beyond its plausible meaning to save the statute.”

Concluding its critique of Barrett’s nomination, HRC wrote, “Her hostility towards many of society’s most marginalized, victimized, and vulnerable groups raises serious concerns about her ability to be impartial and fairly consider the rights of all who come before the Court, including LGBTQ people.”

To sign up for the Gay City News email newsletter, visit gaycitynews.com/newsletter.

About the Author

Paul Schindler

Paul Schindler is the founding editor of Gay City News.

Related Articles

  • Trump Strips Obamacare’s Transgender Healthcare Protections
  • Torpedo Obamacare, Then Grab a Rose Garden Beer
  • Trump Goes With Scalia Acolyte for High Court
  • Nationwide, Obamacare Supporters Rally

Jobs in New York

Add your job

  • Latham & Watkins LLPAttorney, Corporate
  • Taiga RestauranWaiters, Dishwashers, Kitchen Assistant
  • L.SalzmanCleaning Person

View all jobs…

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

Post an Event

Homage: Queer lineages on video presents
Tomorrow, noon

Homage: Queer lineages on video
Wallach Art Gallery

Murmuration Theatre Co Presents you are
Tomorrow, 7 pm

you are seen (Murmuration Theatre Co @ The Makers’ Space)
Makers’ Space

Meet your new bestie! Go Fish, Girl! is
Tomorrow, 7 pm

Go Fish, Girl! ; Make new friends over board games!
The Tiny Cupboard

Fusing the soul of bluegrass with the sp
Tomorrow, 8 pm

Country Gongbang
LeFrak Concert Hall

ARIADNE IN AMERICA is a queer chamber op
Tomorrow, 8 pm

Ariadne in America
the cell theatre

Raise a glass with us for an evening of
Oct. 11, 5 pm

Future Classics Fundraiser
Flushing Town Hall

Ever since the release of her debut feat
Oct. 11, 6 pm

FEMALE MISBEHAVIOR: THE FILMS OF MONIKA TREUT
Anthology Film Archives

WINNER – BEST ONE MAN SHOW – UNITED SOLO
Oct. 24, 7 pm

Under the Rainbow @ The United Solo Festival
Theatre Row, 410 W 42nd Street, NY, NY

View All Events…

Arts

  • Liam Oh as Ray McAffey and Miles Heizer as Cameron Cope in "Boots." ‘Boots’ marches through life in the marines in the shadow of ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’
  • (L to R) Ayo Edebiri as Maggie and Julia Roberts as Alma in "After the Hunt." ‘After the Hunt’ mistakes arbitrary plot twists for complex thought
  • Jay Som's 'Belong' debuts Oct. 10. October LGBTQ music: Khalid’s ‘After the Sun Goes Down’ and Jay Som’s ‘Belong’
  • ACT UP members join ‘Fairyland’ screening and Q&A
  • “Kiss of the Spider Woman," directed by Bill Condon, opens October 9 in wide release. ‘Kiss Of The Spider Woman’ updates its perspective, 40 years after the original

Politics

  • Erik Bottcher at his 2021 election night party at The Chelsea Bell. Bottcher raises $683k in first 24 hours after announcing potential Congressional bid
  • Councilmember Erik Bottcher speaks at a Sept. 30 rally against the Trump administration's anti-trans funding cuts. Denouncing Trump, Bottcher explores bid for Congress in race to replace Nadler
  • Kei Williams, the executive director of New Pride Agenda, delivers remarks on the steps of The Tweed Courthouse in Manhattan on Sept. 30. Advocates rally against Trump administration’s anti-trans funding cuts in NYC
  • Mayor Eric Adams speaks during a press conference at City Hall. Mayor Adams to ‘dig into’ authority to ‘change’ student bathroom policy
  • Zohran Mamdani man in beard speaking in microphone at rallyNYC Mayor’s Race: Mamdani says he’ll apologize for past social media post that blasted NYPD as racist

Crime

  • Jacob Zieben-Hood, 34, was found dead hours after he allegedly told his father by phone that his husband was targeting him with knives. Manhattan DA charges man in series of alleged attacks against slain husband
  • Penn Station on Aug. 27, 2025. Lawmakers demand answers from Amtrak after hundreds of arrests at Penn Station men’s bathroom
  • Law enforcement officers set up barriers after a shooting at Annunciation Church, which is also home to an elementary school, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S. August 27, 2025. In wake of Minneapolis shooting, White House falsely suggests link between gender-affirming care and violence
  • Convicted rapist of transgender woman in Manhattan walks in handcuffs.Convicted Manhattan rapist gets 12 years in prison, feels wrath of his transgender victim at sentencing hearing
  • U.S. rapper Lil Nas X, alongside his attorney Christy O'Connor, attends his arraignment at Los Angeles Superior Court in Los Angeles, California, U.S., August 25, 2025. Lil Nas X charged with four felonies after arrest in Los Angeles

Perspectives

  • The right to use the bathroom is increasingly under threat in New York City. Stop the disgraceful attacks on bathrooms
  • Erik Bottcher at his 2021 election night party at The Chelsea Bell. Erik Bottcher is the voice we need in Congress
  • Émilia Decaudin For New York to remain a queer haven, we must build more homes
  • Ronald Porcelli is the director of the NYC Unity Project. How the NYC Unity Project’s Family Acceptance of LGBTQ+ Youth Initiative heals families and saves LGBTQ+ lives
  • The 2025 NYC Dyke March. Letter to the editor: NYC Dyke March’s policy represents deliberate exclusion rooted in religious and political identity

LGBTQ+ events in NYC

New York’s Job Board

More from Around NYC

op-ed-outdoor-dining-permanent-2023-06-09-bk01,BC,PRINT_WEB
Brooklyn Paper

Brooklyn lawmaker pushes to bring back year-round outdoor dining

mosholu concourse
Bronx Times

Housing lottery underway for 55 units at Mosholu Concourse Apartments in Bedford Park, rent starts at $1,604

Dorothy Providence after Worship Service on Sunday at Fenimore Street United Methodist Church in Brooklyn.
Caribbean Life

Dorothy Providence breast cancer-free for 36 years

Emil Heineman Islanders
AMNY

Emil Heineman finally getting appreciation from Islanders team that wanted him

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Networking Events
  • Advertise
  • © Gay City News 2025. Schneps Media
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sections
  • Jobs
  • Games
  • Events
  • Contact